Life-threatening birth experiences among Medicaid enrollees vary widely by state and race-ethnicity

Threefold difference between lowest rate of severe childbirth complications in Utah compared to highest in D.C.

5:00 PM

Author | Beata Mostafavi

map of the united states rate of life threatening childbirth complications by state
Justine Ross/Michigan Medicine

The risk of life-threatening maternal complications from childbirth may be higher depending on where you live, a study finds.

For Medicaid enrollees in Utah, the rate of “near miss” instances that could have led to the death of a birthing person during pregnancy or delivery was the lowest in the United States, occurring among 80 per 10,000 live births.

Meanwhile, on the other side of the country in Washington D.C., the rate of such cases was nearly three times higher – 210 per 10,000 deliveries.

The drivers for these unexpected maternal outcomes, referred to as severe maternal morbidity, also varied by race and ethnicity, according to the research in Obstetrics & Gynecology, or The Green Journal.

“Our findings suggest wide variation in rates and potential causes of severe maternal morbidity by state, and by race and ethnicity across and within states,” said lead author Lindsay Admon, M.D., M.Sc., an assistant professor of obstetrics and gynecology at the University of Michigan Medical School and obstetrician-gynecologist at U-M Health Von Voigtlander Women’s Hospital.“This data highlights states that have the greatest burden of severe maternal complications and may help guide and tailor interventions aimed at reducing morbidity among those at highest risk.”

Researchers analyzed national data from 4.8 million live births among Medicaid enrollees (average age of 27) between 2016 and 2018, tracking unanticipated outcomes resulting in significant short- or long-term health consequences within six weeks of delivery.

Overall, 146 out of every 10,000 live births among Medicaid enrollees in the U.S. involved serious complications, according to the study.

Differences in maternal morbidity rates across states and by race and ethnicity

The findings come on the heels of alarming data from the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention finding a sharp rise in maternal deaths during the pandemic.

Medicaid finances slightly more than two in five births in the U.S. and a disproportionate number of births to individuals with the greatest risk of experiencing severe maternal complications and death, including Black and Indigenous populations, rural residents, and those living in lower income ZIP codes.

When we look at maternal health across populations within states, we can see that some communities are performing much better than others with respect to life-threatening labor and delivery outcomes.”

- Lindsay Admon, M.D., M.Sc.

More than two thirds of individuals with live births in the study were eligible for Medicaid for income while a smaller proportion qualified due to pregnancy. 

Medicaid enrollees are at the highest risk of maternal morbidity and mortality,” Admon said. “Many states are pursuing clinical interventions and health policies designed to address maternal health inequities through Medicaid programs. But until now, we haven’t had a big picture view of health outcomes on a geographic and demographic level to inform these decisions.”

The five states with the highest rates of severe maternal morbidity included D.C., California, Nevada, New Jersey, and New York. Meanwhile, rates for Utah, Maryland, Rhode Island, Nebraska, and New Hampshire fell in the bottom tenth percentile.

But state-by-state outcomes differed depending on a person’s racial or ethnic group.  Among deliveries to non-Hispanic Black individuals, the three states with the highest rates of severe maternal morbidity were Alaska, New York, and New Jersey while states with the lowest rates were in New Mexico, North Dakota, and Utah.

For white individuals, California, West Virginia, and South Carolina ranked highest for severe adverse maternal health outcomes while the lowest rates were found in Utah, North Dakota and Maine.

Drivers of maternal morbidity

The leading factor linked with severe maternal morbidity among all Medicaid enrollees was eclampsia, a rare but life-threatening complication from high blood pressure during pregnancy that can cause seizures. But conditions varied across states and by race and ethnicity within states.

In Texas, for example, eclampsia was the top driver of potentially fatal maternal outcomes overall among people covered by Medicaid. However, non-Hispanic Black Texans experienced acute heart failure as the leading driver, and white Texans experienced sepsis as the leading driver of maternal health outcomes.

“Previous research suggests that pre-existing chronic conditions like obesity, diabetes, and mental health conditions are linked to greater risk for adverse maternal health outcomes,” Admon said. “We need to focus on interventions that improve the overall health of our reproductive-aged population and identify clinical, societal, and structural barriers that may prevent individuals from achieving optimal health before pregnancy.”

Since maternal mortality is a relatively rare event, Admon adds, studying severe maternal morbidity to understand “near miss” events that could have resulted in an in-hospital maternal death may help efforts to mitigate the most adverse maternal health outcomes.

“When we look at maternal health across populations within states, we can see that some communities are performing much better than others with respect to life-threatening labor and delivery outcomes,” Admon said. “This added nuance will be helpful to clinicians, policymakers and advocacy groups who are committed to strategies to improve maternal health across the country.”

This study was selected as the “editor’s pick” for the April 2023 edition of The Green Journal.

Additional authors include Samantha Auty,M.S., Jamie Daw, Ph.D., Katy Kozhimannil, Ph.D.,M.P.A., Eugene Declerq, Na Wang, Ph.D., and Sarah Gordon, Ph.D.

Study cited:State Variation in Severe Maternal Morbidity Among Medicaid Enrollees,” The Green Journal. DOI: 10.1097/AOG.000000000000514


More Articles About: Children's Health C.S. Mott Children’s Hospital Von Voigtlander Women's Hospital Health Care Delivery, Policy and Economics High-Risk Pregnancy childbirth obstetrics Race and Ethnicity Women's Health Prenatal Care Disparity Community Health Gynecology
Health Lab word mark overlaying blue cells
Health Lab

Explore a variety of healthcare news & stories by visiting the Health Lab home page for more articles.

Media Contact Public Relations

Department of Communication at Michigan Medicine

[email protected]

734-764-2220

Stay Informed

Want top health & research news weekly? Sign up for Health Lab’s newsletters today!

Subscribe
Featured News & Stories Illustration of teenager lying in bed while images above depict an F grade on paper and classroom
Health Lab
2 in 3 parents say their adolescent or teen worries about how sick days may impact grades
National poll: 1 in 5 parents consider if their child needs a mental health day; 1 in 4 say attendance policies are challenging for kids with medical conditions
Older couple holding hands
Health Lab
In sickness and in health, older couples mostly make Medicare moves together
A new study suggests the need for more efforts to help both members of a couple weigh and choose their Medicare options together, because most changes of plan occur with both members of the couple changing from the same option to the same option.
Speculum illustration including a gloved hand holding a swab in front of microscopic cells
Health Lab
U.S. could cut cervical cancer cases, deaths by up to 20% if more patients followed up after screening, study suggests
Many women don’t get cervical cancer screening such as Pap tests, or don’t go for follow up diagnostic tests; a new study shows what could happen if all of them did.
gun with lock on it with key there gun is in black and background yellow and lock is white
Health Lab
Michigan’s new firearm injury prevention laws: What everyone should know
Michigan has a set of new laws related to firearms, all designed to reduce the risk of injury and death across the state.
Spilled pills next to a stethoscope and pile of cash
Health Lab
Drug pricing program improved prostate cancer treatment adherence
Socially vulnerable patients were more likely to stick with oral medications when treated at a hospital participating in 340B program, suggesting these hospitals may have more resources to help patients.
Health Lab
Fitness instructor, backpacker returns to active lifestyle after years of pain from endometriosis
Woman seeks answers for painful periods, leading to the discovery of endometriosis, large ovarian cysts, organ inflammation and appendix cancer